Research philosophy and theory development: writing a meaningful methodology section
Many quantitative dissertations begin their methodology chapter with “this study adopts positivism” and never return to the statement. A philosophy section matters only when it explains your choice of question, evidence and analytical methods.
Research philosophy concerns beliefs and assumptions about developing knowledge: ontology asks what reality is, epistemology asks what counts as knowledge, and axiology considers the researcher's values. There is no universally best philosophy. Your assumptions should fit your approach to theory development, whether deductive, inductive or abductive, and the methods you actually use.
1. Research philosophy and why it belongs in your dissertation
Saunders et al. (2023, p. 131) define research philosophy as a system of beliefs and assumptions about the development of knowledge. Researchers make assumptions about reality, knowledge and their own values at every stage, whether they recognise them or not. Those assumptions shape their understanding of the research question, their methods and their interpretation of results.
The book presents these decisions through the “research onion”. Philosophy and approaches to theory development form its outer layers, followed by methodological choice, strategy and time horizon; data collection and analysis techniques occupy the centre. The layers are related without mechanically determining each other: a straight line cannot be drawn from one philosophy to one technique (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 128–129).
Management researchers do not agree on one philosophy. Saunders et al. (2023, p. 133) take a pluralist position: each offers a useful perspective. Recognise your own assumptions, name them and make sure your design is consistent with them.
Journal articles often leave readers to infer philosophy from the methods. In a dissertation, an explicit commitment and its methodological implications help readers understand the basis on which your conclusions should be judged (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 132).
2. Three types of assumption
| Assumption | Central question | Objectivist end | Subjectivist end |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ontology | What is the nature of reality? | Real, external, a single ordered reality consisting of things | Conventional, socially constructed, multiple realities consisting of processes |
| Epistemology | What knowledge and evidence are acceptable? | Natural-science assumptions; facts, numbers, observable phenomena and general laws | Humanities assumptions; opinions, narratives, texts, images, attributed meanings and particular contexts |
| Axiology | What role do values play? | Value-free; researcher detached | Value-bound; researcher involved and reflexive |
The book illustrates ontology through resistance to organisational change. If resistance is assumed to be harmful, researchers ask how to remove it. If it is understood as an ongoing process that can expose weaknesses in a change programme, they ask how it might be used constructively. Different assumptions about the same phenomenon generate different questions (Thomas and Hardy, as cited in Saunders et al., 2023, p. 134).
For axiology, the book suggests writing a statement of personal values relevant to the topic. Choosing face-to-face interviews rather than an anonymous questionnaire already expresses a preference for particular kinds of evidence (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 135).
3. Four paradigms for organisational analysis
Burrell and Morgan combine objective–subjective assumptions with regulation–radical change to distinguish four paradigms. Regulation seeks improvements within existing organisational arrangements; radical change questions those arrangements (as cited in Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 140–142).
| Paradigm | Position | Main concern |
|---|---|---|
| Functionalist | Objective; regulation | Rational explanation and recommendations within existing structures; common in management research and often linked to positivism |
| Interpretive | Subjective; regulation | How people understand their world and attach meaning to organisational life |
| Radical structuralist | Objective; radical change | Structural power and conflict; often linked to critical realism |
| Radical humanist | Subjective; radical change | Power and oppression examined through language and social construction |
The terms paradigm, philosophy and methodology are sometimes used interchangeably. In this book, a paradigm is a set of basic assumptions shared by a research community; philosophy concerns knowledge, reality and values; methodology concerns how research should be conducted (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 143).
4. Five research philosophies
| Philosophy | Ontology | Epistemology | Axiology | Typical methodology |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Positivism | Real, external, independent and ordered | Scientific method, measurable facts, general laws, causal explanation and prediction | Researcher seeks detachment and neutrality | Usually deductive, structured, large samples and quantitative measurement |
| Critical realism | Stratified empirical, actual and real domains; objective structures | Historically situated knowledge and historical causal explanation | Value-laden; seeks to minimise bias | Retroduction, historical analysis and multiple forms of evidence |
| Interpretivism | Complex, socially constructed through culture and language; multiple meanings | Narratives, perceptions and interpretations; new understanding | Researcher involved and reflexive | Usually inductive, qualitative and in-depth with small samples |
| Postmodernism | Conventional and constructed through power relations | Challenges dominant accounts of truth and recovers marginalised voices | Power-sensitive and radically reflexive | Deconstruction of texts and realities; qualitative inquiry |
| Pragmatism | Reality understood through the practical consequences of ideas | Knowledge that supports successful action; problem-centred inquiry | Researcher's values and doubts guide inquiry | Question-led; mixed methods, multiple methods and action research |
Positivism
Positivists seek observable, measurable facts and causal relationships that support law-like generalisations. Hypotheses are commonly developed from existing theory and tested. Positivism does not necessarily begin with theory: early positivists advocated induction, although contemporary positivist studies are predominantly deductive. Choosing a problem, questionnaire items or experimental conditions can still introduce values (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 146–147).
Critical realism
Critical realism distinguishes what we observe from the wider reality producing it. In Bhaskar's stratified model, the empirical domain of observations lies within the actual domain of events, while underlying structures and causal mechanisms belong to the real domain. The book contrasts a direct-realist referee who calls events as they are with a critical-realist referee who calls them as they appear to that observer (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 148–149).
Interpretivism
People create meanings, so interpretivists argue that social research should not simply imitate natural science. Phenomenology attends to lived experience, hermeneutics to texts and symbols, and symbolic interactionism to interaction. Researchers need empathy and should seek to understand participants' worlds from their perspectives (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 149–150).
Postmodernism and pragmatism
Postmodernism examines language and power, deconstructing accepted realities to reveal excluded perspectives. Pragmatism starts with a practical problem and selects methods that yield relevant, credible evidence for action. The book cautions against choosing pragmatism merely to avoid understanding other philosophies (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 150–153).
A questionnaire study testing theory-derived hypotheses often fits positivism and deduction. A study that develops explanations through interviews and subsequently tests them may instead involve abductive reasoning and a pragmatic or critical-realist position. Describe what the research actually does rather than assigning a philosophy from the software used.
5. Deduction, induction and abduction
Drawing on Ketokivi and Mantere (2010), Saunders et al. (2023, pp. 153–154) distinguish three forms of reasoning. Deduction derives conclusions logically from theoretical premises: if valid premises are true, the conclusion follows. Induction contains a logical gap between observations and conclusions, which can be supported rather than guaranteed. Abduction begins with a surprising fact and seeks premises capable of explaining it.
| Criterion | Deduction | Induction | Abduction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Logic | True premises entail the conclusion | Known premises generate an untested conclusion | Known premises generate a testable conclusion |
| Generalisation | General to particular | Particular to general | Moves between particular and general |
| Use of data | Evaluates propositions and hypotheses derived from theory | Explores phenomena, identifies themes and develops a conceptual framework | Explores, builds a framework and tests it with further evidence |
| Theory | Tests or challenges | Generates and develops | Generates or modifies, combining existing theory |
| Common associations | Positivism | Interpretivism | Critical realism, postmodernism and pragmatism |
Six stages of deduction
Develop a hypothesis
Propose ideas, premises or relationships between concepts that contribute to a theory.
Deduce testable propositions
Use the literature and the conditions under which the theory applies.
Examine the reasoning
Compare it with existing theory and ask whether it advances understanding.
Collect and analyse data
Operationalise concepts and evaluate the premises.
If the evidence does not fit
Reject or revise the theory and begin the process again.
If the evidence fits
The theory is corroborated rather than permanently proved.
These stages are attributed to Blaikie and Priest in Saunders et al. (2023, p. 156). Deduction commonly involves causal relationships, operationalisation and carefully sampled evidence for generalisation. The book's example of absence from work in one shop also illustrates the limits: findings about younger, shorter-tenured staff in that shop cannot establish a universal pattern.
Inductive researchers may interview staff and managers before developing theory. Abductive researchers move between theory and evidence, exploring, building and testing with existing and new data. Critical realists often use retroduction to emphasise reasoning backwards towards mechanisms that could have produced the observed phenomenon (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 157–158).
6. Choosing an appropriate approach
Understanding your approach helps you make informed design decisions, recognise suitable strategies and adapt when access or initial understanding is limited (Easterby-Smith et al., as cited in Saunders et al., 2023, p. 158). Consider:
- Philosophy: positivism commonly favours deduction and interpretivism induction; other positions may favour abduction.
- Literature: established literature can support deductive hypotheses; unfamiliar topics may call for induction; evidence from other settings but little from your own may motivate abduction.
- Time: deduction is often easier to schedule; induction and abduction may take longer and may not produce clear patterns.
- Your preferences and tolerance for uncertainty: these are also legitimate considerations.
The boundary between deduction and induction is not rigid. Combining them can be beneficial, even when one approach predominates (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 158).
7. A reporting template, common mistakes and checklist
Illustrative paragraph for a quantitative survey dissertation
This study adopts a positivist philosophy. Ontologically, [concepts such as trust and intention to use] are treated as independent of the researcher and measurable with validated instruments. Epistemologically, acceptable knowledge consists of observable relationships evaluated using quantitative evidence from [sample]. Axiologically, the researcher seeks independence through a structured self-administered questionnaire. A deductive approach is used: hypotheses are derived from [theory] and evaluated using [analysis]. Findings support or fail to support these hypotheses within [context]; they do not establish applicability to every setting.
| Weak statement | Problem | Better approach |
|---|---|---|
| “The study is positivist” without explanation | No assumptions or implications | Connect ontology, epistemology and axiology with the design |
| Copying five definitions before choosing one | Length without relevance | Explain the selected position and reasons |
| Claiming deduction when the model emerged from interviews | Mismatch with the actual reasoning | Explain abductive or combined reasoning where appropriate |
| Choosing pragmatism only because methods are mixed | A label replaces an argument | Explain why the problem requires multiple kinds of knowledge |
| “The hypothesis has been proved” | Testing cannot establish permanent truth | Use “supported” or “corroborated” within the study's scope |
Checklist
- State the chosen philosophy and its ontological, epistemological and axiological assumptions.
- Align assumptions with the question, evidence and analysis.
- Explain your approach to theory development and the reasons for it.
- Describe the actual sequence of work rather than a generic template.
- Use conclusions appropriate to your reasoning: corroboration rather than permanent proof.
Conclusion
The philosophy section is an explanation of why the evidence can address your question and why the findings should be assessed using particular criteria. A short account that connects assumptions with design is more persuasive than pages of copied definitions.
References
- Ketokivi, M., & Mantere, S. (2010). Two strategies for inductive reasoning in organizational research. Academy of Management Review, 35(2), 315–333. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.35.2.zok315
- Saunders, M. N. K., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2023). Research methods for business students (9th ed.). Pearson. Pearson
This methodological overview draws on the listed scholarly sources. Other authors discussed through Saunders et al. (2023) are identified as secondary citations. The reporting paragraph is an illustrative template written for this article.
