Research questions, aims and proposals: turning an idea into a workable plan
A proposal is rarely improved by making its methods more complicated. The more fundamental problems are an overbroad question, objectives that do not lead to an answer, and a theory section that lists authors without explaining relationships.
A sound proposal forms a coherent chain. Its overarching question identifies one or two central abstract concepts and a context; the aim restates that question as a purpose; objectives specify feasible, verifiable steps; theory explains relationships; and methods, time and resources demonstrate that the project can be completed.
1. What makes a good research idea?
Saunders et al. (2023, pp. 30–32) group the qualities of a research idea under suitability, capability and motivation. A suitable idea meets institutional requirements, connects with theory, can be expressed as clear questions and objectives, and promises new insight. Capability means having or learning the necessary skills, with sufficient time, funding and data access. Motivation matters because superficial interest is difficult to sustain throughout a dissertation.
The book offers two useful cautions. First, findings should have value whichever direction they take: a project that matters only if a hypothesis is supported is a gamble (Gill and Johnson, as cited in Saunders et al., 2023). Second, an apparently untouched topic might be genuinely new, might already have been researched under different search terms, or might have attracted little attention because it lacks value.
A fresh perspective is often more feasible than an entirely original subject. Replication in another industry or country can be legitimate when there is a reason to question transferability. Ignoring existing work is not the same as making a contribution (Saunders et al., 2023).
2. Refining the idea
The book recommends combining rational techniques, such as reviewing successful coursework, supervisors' interests, earlier dissertation titles, professional discussions and literature, with creative techniques such as an ideas notebook, relevance trees and brainstorming (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 33). Three refinement approaches are particularly useful:
Delphi technique
Knowledgeable contributors respond anonymously. Their answers are analysed thematically and returned to the group over successive rounds to work towards consensus.
Preliminary inquiry
Read with a sharper focus, speak to experienced people and investigate the organisation where you hope to collect data. Change an infeasible idea early.
Progressive narrowing
Move from a broad field to a topic and then a particular aspect. The book illustrates this by narrowing accounting to financial accounting methods and then activity-based costing.
An employer's project may be larger than a dissertation. Extract a manageable part that interests you, while recognising the ethical and political pressures associated with being an insider researcher (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 41–42).
3. Writing the overarching research question
The overarching question guides the literature, design, access, sampling, data collection, analysis and report structure (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 42). In exploratory qualitative strategies such as ethnography or grounded theory, it may evolve, but an initial question is still needed.
Description or explanation?
Questions may begin with what, when, where, who, why, how or to what extent. A purely descriptive question is easier to answer but may not meet your programme's expectations. Asking how satisfied employees are with a departmental strategy change describes a situation; asking how the change relates to satisfaction, and why, opens a route to explanation (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 53).
Three ways to test your question
| Tool | Meaning | Self-check |
|---|---|---|
| Goldilocks test | Too large, too small, too sensitive, or just right | Is it manageable with my time, skills and context? |
| Russian-doll principle | Strip away unnecessary wording until the core remains | Which words can be removed without changing the meaning? |
| AbC rule | One or two abstract concepts and a context | What is the theoretical focus, and where and with whom will it be studied? |
Too many abstract concepts blur the focus; no context leaves the question without an empirical anchor. The book's organisational-citizenship and turnover-intention example has two concepts situated in the public sector.
A model with five to seven factors can still have an overarching question focused on one or two core concepts, such as trust and purchase intention. Other factors belong in objectives or hypotheses. Listing every factor in the main question can obscure its focus.
4. Aims and specific objectives
The research aim states the purpose of the project, effectively recasting the main question as a statement. Specific objectives or investigative questions then identify the steps needed to achieve it; institutional preferences determine which format to use (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 45–46).
| Criterion | Self-check | Requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Transparency | What does this mean? | Clear, unambiguous meaning |
| Specificity | What will I do? | An understandable purpose and action |
| Relevance | Why am I doing this? | Visible connection with the main question and aim |
| Interconnection | How does it complete the project? | Together the objectives cover the process without gaps |
| Answerability | Can I do it, and obtain the evidence? | Feasible outcomes and identifiable data |
| Measurability | When is it complete? | A recognisable endpoint |
In the book's merger example (Box 2.7), objectives move from describing the change, defining engagement, commitment and development, and assessing effects, to identifying improvements and making recommendations. Students often omit concept definition, even though it connects theory with measurement.
5. The role of theory
Saunders et al. (2023, p. 48) describe theory as evidence-based knowledge used to explain or predict. Whetten (1989) identifies what, how, why, and who–where–when. Concepts and relationships describe a pattern; the “why” supplies explanation, while scope identifies its boundaries.
What theory is not
Sutton and Staw (1995) distinguish theory from references, data, variable lists, diagrams and hypotheses. Each can contribute to theory development or testing but does not itself explain why relationships exist. Likewise, a guiding proposition or concept is not yet a theory.
Arrows and a list of labels such as TPB, TAM or UTAUT are insufficient. Explain in words why each relationship is expected and which mechanism from the underlying theory supports it.
A proportionate theoretical contribution
The book distinguishes grand, middle-range and substantive theory. A master's dissertation commonly contributes to substantive understanding within a time, setting, population or problem. Repeated substantive explanations may inform middle-range theory (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 54). Corley and Gioia (2011) assess contributions through originality, incremental or revelatory, and utility, scientific or practical. A study can provide both forms of utility.
| Component | Question | In your proposal |
|---|---|---|
| What | Which concepts or variables? | Definitions and measures |
| How | How are they related? | Model, direction and hypotheses |
| Why | Why should the relationships exist? | Theory-based reasoning for each hypothesis |
| Who, where, when | Under which conditions does the explanation apply? | Context, participants, scope and limitations |
6. Why a proposal is needed and how it is assessed
A proposal is a structured plan that forces you to consider what, why, how, when and where, and guides the project through its stages (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 55). General assessment criteria include coherence, ethics and feasibility.
- Coherence: sections fit together and guide the work.
- Ethics: explain applicable review requirements, data storage, anonymity and confidentiality.
- Feasibility: demonstrate time, access, funding and analytical capability.
The book cautions against research driven by a predetermined answer: if the result is already assumed, the purpose of investigation becomes unclear (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 57).
7. Structuring a proposal
| Part | Core content | Writing advice |
|---|---|---|
| Title | Summarise the question and concepts | Remove redundant wording; revise it when the question changes |
| Background | Problem, rationale, aims and place in the literature | Introduce key sources and theories rather than a full review |
| Question and objectives | Overarching question, aim and objectives or investigative questions | Lead to observable outcomes |
| Methods | Philosophy, design, population, sample, collection, analysis and ethics | Explain how instruments will be used; a complete questionnaire is not always required here |
| Timescale | Stages and durations, commonly in a Gantt chart | Allow realistic time and recognise sequential dependencies |
| Resources | Budget, data access, equipment and software | Show that analytical skills or support are available |
| References | Key theoretical and methodological sources | Length alone does not establish quality |
The background introduces the problem, explains why the question matters and connects it with scholarship. Distinguish your personal interest from the reason the research deserves to be done. The latter may concern applying, developing or testing theory in a specific context (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 58).
The book notes proposals that promise extensive data collection but barely consider analysis. Identify the techniques, software, skills and support needed to turn the data into an answer (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 60–62).
8. Example, common mistakes and checklist
Illustrative example written for this article
Title: Trust and intention to use e-wallets among older adults in Ho Chi Minh City.
Question: To what extent, and why, is trust related to older adults' intention to use e-wallets in Ho Chi Minh City?
Aim: To assess the relationship between trust and intention to use e-wallets and explain its proposed mechanism.
Objectives: Define trust, intention and relevant concepts from the underlying theory; measure trust and intention; evaluate the proposed relationships; interpret findings against theory and evidence; and develop implications for e-wallet providers.
| Weak approach | Problem | Better approach |
|---|---|---|
| Listing seven factors in the main question | Unclear theoretical focus | Keep one or two central concepts in the overarching question |
| Only asking about satisfaction levels | Only descriptive outcomes | Where appropriate, add a relationship and an explanatory question |
| “Find out about…” as an objective | No identifiable endpoint | Use identify, measure, evaluate or propose |
| Omitting concept definition | Break between theory and measurement | Define and justify the concepts |
| Listing theories and showing a diagram | No explanation of why | Explain mechanisms behind the relationships |
| No timetable or analysis plan | Feasibility cannot be assessed | Add realistic stages and analytical techniques |
Before submission
- Explain what you will do, why and why it matters.
- Connect the project with previous studies and theory.
- State the overarching question, aim and objectives or investigative questions.
- Describe design, required evidence, participants, sampling and access.
- Explain how collection and analysis lead to a theoretically informed answer.
- Anticipate data-quality problems and responses.
- Address ethics at each stage.
Checklist paraphrased from Saunders et al. (2023, p. 56, Box 2.11).
Conclusion
Difficulties in results and conclusions often begin in the proposal. Broad questions produce vague conclusions, unmeasurable objectives hide the endpoint, and theory lists leave nothing to discuss. Revising the main question and objectives until they fit together is a valuable investment in the entire dissertation.
References
- Corley, K. G., & Gioia, D. A. (2011). Building theory about theory building: What constitutes a theoretical contribution? Academy of Management Review, 36(1), 12–32. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2009.0486
- Saunders, M. N. K., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2023). Research methods for business students (9th ed.). Pearson. Pearson
- Sutton, R. I., & Staw, B. M. (1995). What theory is not. Administrative Science Quarterly, 40(3), 371–384. https://doi.org/10.2307/2393788
- Whetten, D. A. (1989). What constitutes a theoretical contribution? Academy of Management Review, 14(4), 490–495. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.1989.4308371
This article synthesises the listed scholarly sources for methodological guidance. The example in Section 8 was written for illustration. Follow your institution's proposal requirements.
