Secondary data: where to find it and how to assess it for your dissertation
An existing dataset can save months of collection, but it was created for somebody else's question. Your task is to show that its measures, coverage and quality are suitable for yours.
Secondary data were collected for another purpose and are reanalysed for your study. They can save money and time, offer strong coverage and enable longitudinal work, but you cannot control the original measures, sample or changes in definitions. Assess overall suitability, detailed suitability, and costs against benefits before committing to a dataset.
1. What are secondary data?
Saunders et al. (2023, p. 342) include both raw data and published summaries originally collected for another purpose. Once assessed as suitable, they can support new interpretations and conclusions. Statistical agencies, industry associations, news archives and organisational records offer alternatives to collecting a new survey.
The primary–secondary distinction depends on perspective. Schindler (2022, p. 57) uses annual reports to illustrate this: a report may be a primary documentary source for a company's official position, while its figures are secondary evidence assembled from underlying records. Internal KPI dashboards can similarly be reused.
When you did not design the original collection, someone else selected the questions, sample and coding. Those decisions become constraints on your analysis.
2. Three groups of secondary data
Secondary evidence can be numerical or qualitative, structured in tables and databases or unstructured as texts, audio and images. Saunders et al. (2023, pp. 345–357) distinguish survey, documentary and multiple-source data. Their discussion, drawing on Taylor, also highlights the large volume of unstructured information.
| Group | Subgroups | Examples | Main consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Survey | Censuses; continuous or regular surveys; one-off surveys | Population census, household living-standards surveys, business surveys | Usually structured and quantitative; definitions, coverage and response must be examined |
| Documentary | Text; sound; images and video | Minutes, email, websites, reports, customer reviews, podcasts and video | Interpret within the creator's perspective and purpose |
| Multiple source | Cross-sectional, longitudinal or continuously updated | Company financial databases, regional yearbooks, transaction data and big data | Someone has already combined underlying sources |
Censuses can offer broad coverage and detailed documentation; one-off surveys may be more topic-specific but harder to obtain at microdata level (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 346). Multiple-source evidence is increasingly important. The book describes big data through volume, velocity and variety, while cautioning that specialist software and computational requirements may make a resource impractical for a student project (pp. 357–358).
A single source rarely contains every required variable. Combining sources into an analytical dataset is therefore common and can take considerable time (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 350).
3. Why consider existing data?
| Benefit | Value for a dissertation | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Time and cost savings | More time for theory, analysis and interpretation; sometimes the only feasible route | Saunders et al., p. 358 |
| Potentially strong quality | Established sampling and quality-control procedures, sometimes national coverage | Bryman and Bell, p. 123 |
| Subgroup analysis | Large samples can support groups a small new survey would miss | Bryman and Bell, pp. 124–125 |
| Longitudinal and international comparisons | Access to multiple years or countries within a limited project | Saunders et al., p. 359; Bryman and Bell, p. 125 |
| Non-reactive evidence | Collection has already occurred, often with de-identification; review requirements must still be checked | Saunders et al., p. 359 |
| Verification | Accessible data allow others to examine the analysis | Saunders et al., p. 360 |
A dataset is not exhausted by its first analysis: different relationships or analytical techniques can produce new understanding. Reusing evidence also respects participants' investment of time. Some funders require applicants to check whether suitable evidence already exists before financing new collection (Bryman and Bell, 2019, pp. 123, 126). Saunders et al. (2023, pp. 359–360), drawing on Dale and colleagues, use reanalysis of medical records to illustrate how evidence can answer questions beyond its original purpose.
4. Risks you must evaluate
The common difficulty is that the data were designed for another question (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 360–363; Bryman and Bell, 2019, p. 127).
| Risk | Manifestation | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose mismatch | Outdated information, inconsistent collection or omitted topics | Saunders et al., pp. 360–361 |
| Access and cost | Commercial reports or custom tables require payment or permission | Saunders et al., p. 361 |
| Aggregation and definitions | Only grouped values are available, or questions change between waves | Saunders et al., p. 361 |
| Limited quality control | Nonresponse, misreporting and incomplete coverage affect even official figures | Saunders et al., p. 362; Bryman and Bell, p. 127 |
| Selective presentation | Organisations highlight favourable information; online reviews may be manipulated | Saunders et al., pp. 362–363 |
| Complexity | Hundreds of variables, unfamiliar coding and household–individual structures | Bryman and Bell, p. 127 |
| Missing key variables | The required concept is absent or measured inconsistently | Bryman and Bell, p. 127 |
Ecological fallacy
Do not use regional aggregates to infer individual behaviour. The unit represented by the data must match the inference being made. Robinson (1950) showed that aggregate correlations can differ markedly, even in direction, from individual-level correlations; Bryman and Bell (2019, p. 127) discuss the implications for secondary analysis.
If your observations are provinces, your conclusions concern provinces. A relationship between provincial governance scores and provincial investment differs from a claim that firms rating government more positively invest more. The latter requires suitable firm-level evidence.
Official statistics may measure something different
Distinguish survey statistics from administrative records. Recorded violations reflect enforcement and reporting as well as underlying behaviour; an inspection campaign can increase recorded offences without an equivalent behavioural change. Unemployment indicators may exclude discouraged workers depending on the definition. Compare suitable representative-survey evidence where possible (Bryman and Bell, 2019, pp. 127–128).
5. Vietnam: changing definitions and administrative boundaries
The book's example of marital-status categories changing between UK censuses shows why apparently identical variables may not be comparable over time (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 361–362). Boundary changes and revised indicators create similar issues in Vietnamese data.
Provinces and centrally governed cities covered by the PCI 2.0 framework described by VCCI in 2026.
Indicators: 111 from business surveys and 26 from official statistical data.
Inherited indicators, alongside 34 new indicators.
VCCI's announcement of 9 May 2026 described PCI 2.0 as scheduled for release on 15 May, with three pillars and ten subindices. A multi-year provincial analysis must therefore decide how earlier provinces map onto the new boundaries and which indicators remain comparable. A new composite index should not simply be appended to the old series without checking definitions.
The National Statistics Office's account of the Vietnam Household Living Standards Survey also illustrates changing content. It describes biennial even-year collection during 2002–2010 and annual collection during 2011–2024, with a narrower set of topics in odd years. A project requiring detailed housing or healthcare-expenditure variables must check the questionnaire for each wave rather than assume those variables exist in every year (National Statistics Office, 2026; Saunders et al., 2023, p. 373).
Obtain every wave's questionnaire and methodology. Build a crosswalk showing question wording, response options and geographic units for each analytical variable. Resolve and report mismatches in the methodology chapter.
6. Finding and locating data
Saunders et al. (2023, pp. 364–368) describe an iterative detective process.
Identify what you need
Derive variables or qualitative themes from the question, objectives and literature. For deductive quantitative work, list requirements as carefully as you would design a questionnaire.
Estimate whether it exists
Check data sources in published studies, then consult libraries, supervisors, statistical agencies and professional associations.
Retrieve the actual resource
Repositories may offer a direct download; organisational access may require lengthy negotiation.
Look outside your own industry. Environmental, legal, social and government sources can be especially valuable for business research (Schindler, 2022, p. 57).
7. Assessing suitability at three levels
Apply the same care as you would to primary evidence. Ask for a sample and documentation before committing, and stop if an essential level fails (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 369–370).
Level 1: overall suitability
Measurement validity: does the information represent the required concept? Production output is not sales. Minutes may omit material a chair did not want recorded. Review how earlier studies have handled the same source and acknowledge unresolved limitations (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 371).
Coverage: does the resource cover the intended population, period and location? Will enough observations remain after excluding irrelevant cases? An unmeasured variable may be tolerable for some descriptive questions but seriously weaken an explanatory model (pp. 371–373).
Level 2: detailed suitability
Reliability: identify who is responsible, related publications, contact information and provenance. An academic-sounding institutional name is not independent evidence of quality (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 373).
Validity and credibility: examine who collected the evidence, sampling, response rates, sampling error, circumstances and instruments. Blogs or minutes may be evidence of the author's perspective rather than an objective record. Always check denominators: a 50% increase from two to three differs greatly from a 20% increase from 1,000 to 1,200 (pp. 374–376).
Measurement bias: look for deliberate distortion, changing collection practices and techniques that do not measure the intended topic. Independent sources can help assess consistency, though agreement alone does not remove every bias (pp. 376–377).
Level 3: costs and benefits
Consider money, search time, access negotiations and conversion or entry work. A spreadsheet may save considerable effort. Imperfect data may still answer part of the question if their limitations are compatible with the proposed inference; availability alone is not sufficient justification (Saunders et al., 2023, p. 377).
Schindler's five online-source criteria
| Criterion | Questions |
|---|---|
| Purpose | Why does the source exist, and how do its interests shape the information? |
| Scope | How current, comprehensive and geographically relevant is it? |
| Authority | Who created or sponsored it, with which expertise and underlying sources? |
| Audience | For whom was it produced, and how does that affect presentation? |
| Format | Can the relevant material be located and downloaded in a usable form? |
8. Ethics when reusing evidence
Public access does not automatically remove ethical review. Consider harm, expectations about research use and data management. Obtain permission when required for organisational or members-only material even if you are an employee or member (Saunders et al., 2023, pp. 359, 370–371).
The book discusses a student analysing a vehicle manufacturer's public Facebook page and deciding on anonymisation and face blurring. That context-specific decision is not general permission to reuse identifiable posts. In Vietnam, consider Law No. 91/2025/QH15 and institutional requirements. The research-ethics article develops this issue further.
9. Reporting template, common mistakes and checklist
Illustrative methodology paragraph
The study uses secondary data from [dataset], collected by [organisation] in [year] for [original purpose]. The original sample contained [n] [units], selected using [sampling method], with a response rate of [x%]. Applying [exclusion criteria] left [n′] analytical observations. Variable [A] is measured by [question and options]. Because no direct measure of [concept] is available, [proxy] is used following [author/year]. Between [waves], [wording/definition/boundary] changed; this was handled through [procedure]. Access was granted under [conditions], and the analytical file was de-identified.
| Weak approach | Problem | Better approach |
|---|---|---|
| “Official data are reliable” | Reputation does not establish measurement suitability | Explain collection, sampling, measures and fit |
| Merging years without reviewing questionnaires | Definitions or boundaries may have changed | Create and report a wave-by-wave crosswalk |
| Drawing individual conclusions from provincial data | Ecological fallacy | Match inference to the unit of analysis |
| Using an undisclosed proxy | Implies direct measurement | Name and justify the proxy |
| Scraping posts because they are public | Ignores ethics and personal-data requirements | Obtain review, protect identities and check applicable rules |
Checklist
Condensed from Saunders et al. (2023, pp. 377–378).
- Required concepts are measured directly or through justified proxies.
- Population, geography, period and remaining sample size are appropriate.
- Source, original purpose, audience and interests are understood.
- Collection, sampling, errors and response are documented.
- Definitions and measures have been compared across waves and against independent evidence.
- Permission, ethics and de-identification requirements are addressed.
- Access time, cost and format are proportionate to the benefit.
Conclusion
Secondary analysis has a different burden of justification: demonstrate that someone else's instrument, created for another purpose, measures what your question requires. Most weaknesses can be found before modelling by reading each wave's documentation. Revised Vietnamese administrative boundaries and indicators make that preparation particularly important.
References
Textbooks
- Bryman, A., & Bell, E. (2019). Social research methods (5th Canadian ed.). Oxford University Press.
- Saunders, M. N. K., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2023). Research methods for business students (9th ed.). Pearson. Pearson
- Schindler, P. S. (2022). Business research methods (14th ed.). McGraw-Hill.
Papers, legislation and data sources
- Cục Thống kê. (2026). Kết quả Khảo sát mức sống dân cư Việt Nam năm 2024. Bộ Tài chính. https://www.nso.gov.vn/?p=60506
- Quốc hội. (2025). Luật Bảo vệ dữ liệu cá nhân số 91/2025/QH15. https://thuvienphapluat.vn
- Robinson, W. S. (1950). Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals. American Sociological Review, 15(3), 351–357. https://doi.org/10.2307/2087176
- VCCI. (2026, 9 tháng 5). Lần đầu công bố xếp hạng năng lực cạnh tranh 34 tỉnh, thành phố. Liên đoàn Thương mại và Công nghiệp Việt Nam. https://www.vcci.com.vn
Textbooks are paraphrased with page references; secondary citations are identified. PCI and household-survey details refer to the linked VCCI and statistical-office publications. The reporting template and Vietnamese applications were written for this article.
